8 Safe and Sunny Islands Perfect for a Girlfriend’s Dream Vacation (2 of 5)

2. Aruba

Known as “One Happy Island,” Aruba boasts not just abundant sunshine but also a stellar safety profile. In fact, the 2025 Caribbean Island Safety Index placed it at the top thanks to low crime rates, strong infrastructure, and virtually no exposure to major hurricanes. Stay along Eagle Beach or Palm Beach and you’ll find resort-friendly walkability, clear waters, and that easy “we’re on vacation” feeling. For a girlfriend trip where you want to leave your phone off and your worries behind, Aruba is a smart pick.

3. Cayman Islands

Elegant, calm, and safe, the Cayman Islands combine high-end appeal with travel ease. Recognized among the safest in the Caribbean thanks to very low violent crime and solid tourist infrastructure, the islands are reliable. Think world-class diving at Stingray City, long walks on Seven Mile Beach, and evenings sipping rum cocktails as the sunset paints the sky. It’s a location where you can indulge in luxury without sacrificing peace of mind.